Double Dummy Corner

 

Competition Problem 95a

composed by Sebastian Nowacki
presented for solving in January, 2013

DR6

♠ A432

 AK5

 Q32

♣ K102

♠ J1098

 Q10432

 K7

♣ J6

♠ 76

 876

 A1098

♣ A987

♠ KQ5

 J9

 J654

♣ Q543

South can make three no-trumps against any lead, but how is it done when West leads the ♣J?

Successful solvers:  Steve Bloom, Kukuh Indrayana, F.Y. Sing.  Nobody gave a complete solution to the defence of winning the first club and attacking hearts, so I'm accepting these three but lowering the DR accordingly (obviously it would have been DR8 otherwise).  Note that I've now added an explanation of why a club lead at trick 2 fails.

DDC Home Next problem Previous problem
  Next DR6 Previous DR6
Competition problem archive Next Nowacki problem Previous Nowacki problem

Solution

North covers with the K and East does best to duck.  South comes to hand on a spade and leads a diamond.  West does best to rise with the K (preserving the entry to East) and lead another club.  Again North covers.  East wins and might as well play a third club, taken by South, who leads another diamond to North's Q.  East must win.

A.      If East cashes the good club and leads a diamond,  West is squeezed out of a heart and so North discards a spade. Now the A and K squeeze East.

B.      If East immediately returns a diamond, South wins and plays a spade to the A and a spade back to the K, squeezing a heart from East to leave this ending with South on lead:

♠ 4

 AK5

 none

♣ none

♠ J

 Q104

 none

♣ none

♠ none

 87

 9

♣ 87

♠ none

 J9

 6

♣ 5

A heart (say, the 9) is covered by West and North and West is thrown in with the spade.  If East discards a heart, so does South, and North makes the A5.  Otherwise South discards from the minor suit East keeps and wins the last two tricks with the J and a minor suit winner (or North again wins them with the A5 if West leads the Q).

Added later:

Steve Bloom's submitted solution is identical to the above but he has now emailed me to say that he does not want it to be accepted!  He points out that there's and interesting enough line for declarer if East wins the opening lead and returns a heart, covered all round, then wins the first diamond (capturing the Q) and continues hearts, setting up a winner for East.  If this winner is cashed when West wins the second diamond, South can discard a spade and there's an easy minor suit squeeze; but a black suit return from West breaks up this squeeze and declarer has to fall back on the triple squeeze that arises when the black suit winners are cashed, ending in North.

Added even later:

Trap: If East ducks the first trick and North leads the 10, East wins and returns either a heart, covered all round, or a club to South's Q, West discarding a heart.  In either case West now plays low on South's low diamond lead and East captures the Q with the A.  Again East can now lead either a club or a heart, and if East's choice is a club, West discards the K!  (But leading hearts twice is the easier defence.)

See the solution to Competition Problem #4 for the recommended tabular format if you prefer not to write in English prose.

DDC Home Next problem Previous problem
  Next DR6 Previous DR6
Competition problem archive Next Nowacki problem Previous Nowacki problem

Hugh Darwen, 2012

Date last modified: 11 March, 2017